Scratched sunglasses: can you fix them, and when should you replace them?

Short answer: A scratch in a sunglasses lens cannot really be removed. It is permanent damage to the lens surface, and the popular home fixes – toothpaste, baking soda, polishing pastes – usually make the lens cloudier and can wear away the tint and coatings. A light scratch outside your line of sight is mostly cosmetic and fine to live with. If the scratches sit where you look, blur your view, cause glare or give you tired eyes, it is time for a new pair.

Why scratches can't be polished away

A scratch is a small groove in the lens. To make it disappear, you would have to remove the material around it until the surface is level again – and that changes the shape of the lens, which is what gives you a clear, undistorted view. Optical labs do not "repair" scratched lenses for that reason; an optician will tell you the only real fix is a new lens. Most so-called scratch removers simply fill the groove with wax or oil, so the mark looks smaller for a while and comes back as soon as you clean the lens.

Toothpaste, baking soda and other DIY hacks: don't

You will find plenty of videos on how to remove scratches from sunglasses with things from the kitchen cupboard. Skip them. Opticians warn against these hacks:

  • Toothpaste: it is mildly abrasive. Rubbing it on a lens adds lots of tiny new scratches and can wear away the tint and any coating, leaving the lens hazy.
  • Baking soda: also abrasive, with the same result – a dull, cloudy lens instead of one clear scratch.
  • Car polish, metal polish and glass cleaner: made for other surfaces and can attack plastic lenses and frames.
  • Your T-shirt: rubbing a dusty lens with fabric drags grit across it, which is how many scratches start in the first place.

The honest advice: if the scratch is small, leave it alone and keep the lens clean the right way. Our guide on how to clean sunglasses without scratching shows the method step by step.

Are scratched sunglasses bad for your eyes?

Not in the sense of causing damage. According to the American Academy of Ophthalmology, looking through a scratched lens can be distracting and may lead to eye strain or headaches, but it does not harm the eye itself. Light scratches don't change how a lens protects you, while many deep scratches or worn-off coatings can make your vision less clear and possibly reduce the UV protection.

So the real problems with scratched sunglasses are comfort and clarity. Scratches scatter light, which can show up as streaks or halos when the sun is low, on wet roads or when you face oncoming headlights at dusk. If you need sharp vision – behind the wheel, on a bike, on the water – that matters. Read more about what the label on your lenses means in our guide to UV400 and lens categories.

Fingernail and line test: how bad is the scratch?

  1. Clean the lens first. Rinse with lukewarm water and a drop of mild dish soap, then dry with a soft microfibre cloth. Sometimes the "scratch" turns out to be a smear or dried residue.
  2. Run a fingernail lightly across it. If your nail glides over the mark, it is a fine surface scuff. If it catches, the scratch is deep.
  3. Look through it. Put the sunglasses on and look at straight lines, such as a door frame or a tiled wall, then towards a bright window. If lines bend, or you see a streak or a halo in your normal line of sight, the scratch affects your view.

When to replace scratched sunglasses

  • The scratches are in the centre of the lens, where you naturally look.
  • You notice glare, streaks or halos, especially when driving or in low sun.
  • Your eyes feel tired or you get headaches after wearing them.
  • The lens is cracked or chipped, or the tint or coating is peeling.
  • The lens has turned hazy all over after years of wiping.

A single light scratch near the edge is a different story. If it does not bother you, keep wearing your pair. Not sure whether your sunglasses are simply worn out? Our article on whether sunglasses expire covers the other signs, from loose hinges to frames that no longer fit.

How to stop the next scratch

  • Use the case. Most scratches happen in bags and pockets, next to keys, coins and phones.
  • Never put sunglasses down lens-first. Fold them and place them with the temples down, or back in the case.
  • Rinse before you wipe. Sand, salt and dust are tiny abrasives. Wash them off with water before the cloth touches the lens.
  • Use a clean microfibre cloth – not paper towels, tissues or your sleeve – and wash the cloth now and then.
  • Don't park them on your head. They pick up hair products, stretch at the hinges and fall more easily.
  • Keep them out of a hot car. Heat on the dashboard is hard on both lenses and frames.

What to do with your old pair

A badly scratched pair does not have to end up in the bin. Our guide to recycling old sunglasses explains your options, and a scratched pair can still be handy as a spare for gardening or the beach bag, as long as you don't need it for driving.

Choosing a new pair

If it is time for new sunglasses, every frame in our recycled sunglasses collection is made from 100% recycled plastics with UV400 lenses in recycled PMMA and sturdy 5-barrel hinges. A few classic frames that are easy to wear every day:

  • Morello Black: a scaled-up square classic for a medium to larger fit, and the pair in the photo above.
  • Turco Black: a balanced, medium-size everyday frame with a comfortable saddle bridge.
  • Gallina Black: a clean rectangular front with wide temples.
  • Venturi Green: a slim, compact classic that sits close to the face.
  • Quist Havana: a round frame with a modern, faceted edge.
  • Palazzo Grey: an oversized frame for more coverage.

All of these have category 3 lenses. Always check the lens category and size on the product page before you buy, or browse all our sunglasses. Not sure whether a mark on your lens is a scratch or something else? Just contact us.

Quick FAQ

Can you remove scratches from sunglasses?

No, not properly. A scratch is permanent damage to the lens surface. Fillers can hide it for a while, and abrasive hacks usually make the lens worse.

Does toothpaste remove scratches from sunglasses?

No. Toothpaste is abrasive. It adds fine scratches, can wear away the tint and coatings and often leaves the lens cloudy.

Do scratches affect UV protection?

Light scratches don't change how a lens protects you. Many deep scratches or worn-off coatings can reduce clarity and possibly the UV protection, so replace a badly scratched pair.

Is it bad to wear scratched sunglasses?

It won't damage your eyes, but scratches in your line of sight can cause glare, eye strain and headaches. Replace them if they bother you, and don't drive with lenses that blur your view.

Every ECO SHADES pair comes with a 2-year warranty, and our sunglasses are CE, UKCA and FDA approved. With 30 years of optical experience and 20,000+ happy customers behind our designs, we would rather help you look after the pair you have – and when it is time for a new one, we are here.